April 2025

Candidate experience: how feedback loops drive it forward

Enhance the candidate experience with targeted feedback loops during the hiring process – boosting transparency, trust, and applicant engagement.
Woman holding a digital network of glowing user icons – representing candidate experience, applicant feedback, and modern HR communication.
Looking for new employees?
Do not hesitate to contact us for a free consultation.

The candidate experience is comparable to a test drive in a new car. It offers potential employees an immediate impression of the company's culture, pace and values – just as a test drive promotes an impression of a car's performance, comfort and suitability for one's needs. After that first test drive, a decision is made as to whether or not a purchase will take place. Similarly, candidates assess whether a company is right for them. For recruiters, this is a wonderful opportunity to refine and perfect that first impression. In this article, we'll look at the key role of feedback loops in guiding the candidate experience – to turn initial trials into successful, long-term hires.

Why is it so important to create an exceptional candidate experience? According to IBM, companies that focus on improving the candidate experience report a 70 per cent improvement in the quality of their hires. This significant figure highlights the fact that a positive candidate experience leads to the hiring of above-average talented applicants – and this in turn reflects well on the company's culture and attractiveness to potential applicants. On the other hand, LinkedIn research shows that 84% of candidates expect transparency about corporate culture during the hiring process. Today, job hunting is about more than just compensation. Applicants want to know what everyday life is like at the company and whether the company's values align with their personal and professional expectations.

This consideration of the candidate experience using feedback loops is intended to provide recruiters with strategies for attracting, retaining and winning over the best talent. This ensures a mutual fit that promotes both employee satisfaction and organisational success.

Let's now look at how feedback loops can improve the recruitment process. To do this, we'll break the process down into three distinct phases: preparation, application, and follow-up. Each phase plays a critical role in shaping the candidate experience and how candidates perceive your company.

Pre-Application Phases: Enhancing Engagement from the Start

Awareness Phase: Informative First Impressions 

During the attention phase, you aim to get potential candidates interested in your company. Start feedback loops by observing how applicants interact with your materials. This includes job ads, posts on social media and your website. Use analytics tools to determine which content is well received. Then use these insights to improve your marketing strategies. Continue to craft messages that clearly promote your company culture and values. For example, if articles about company culture are particularly popular, place a stronger focus on this in your communications.

Generating interest: targeted approach

Once potential candidates show interest, it is important to maintain this engagement. Monitor how candidates respond to your campaigns and communications. Use surveys or quick polls to directly gauge their impressions and interests. This feedback will help you understand what motivates candidates to move forward. Adjust your communication materials accordingly. Make sure the content deeply engages candidates and encourages further engagement.

Desire phase: drive engagement

In this phase, candidates are considering whether they want to apply. Again, use feedback loops to tailor your job descriptions and communications to align with candidates' expectations and career goals. To do this, use feedback from previous applicants to identify the most attractive aspects of the position or company. For example, emphasise unique benefits and career opportunities. Or highlight special features of your corporate culture. Interact with potential candidates through webinars or question-and-answer sessions. Such formats provide real-time feedback to dispel doubts and increase the desire to apply.

Integrating Feedback Loops Across Pre-Application Phases

Implementing feedback loops across these pre-application stages significantly enhances the candidate experience by making potential applicants feel valued and understood from the very first interaction. By actively using feedback to adjust and improve every touchpoint, employers demonstrate a commitment to candidate satisfaction and continuous improvement.

Application Phases: Deepening Candidate Engagement Through Feedback

Action phase: A responsive application process

In the action phase, when applicants are officially seeking a job, the implementation of feedback loops begins with making the application process user-friendly and responsive. Immediate automatic confirmations of receipt set an efficient and communicative tone. A follow-up email outlining what applicants can expect next not only keeps them informed but also engaged. Employers should consider collecting feedback on the application process itself, perhaps through a short survey after submission. This can provide insights into potential points of friction or areas for improvement to make the process smoother and more applicant-friendly in the future.

Assessment phase: Constructive assessment feedback

During this phase, applicants often undergo various tests or tasks that assess their suitability for the role. Implementing feedback loops here involves providing detailed feedback on these assessments. This feedback should not only highlight what has been done well, but also offer constructive criticism on areas for improvement. This practice not only supports professional development, but also positively influences the perception of the recruitment process, which they see as a valuable learning experience. Additionally, employers can use the responses and results to refine assessment tools and processes to ensure their fairness and effectiveness.

Interview phase: strategic dialogue enhancement

The interview phase is a critical point for feedback within the candidate journey. After the interviews, it is crucial to provide detailed and timely feedback. This feedback should be tailored to the discussion points of the interview and provide clear insights into how the skills and experience match the company's requirements. Employers should also seek feedback on the interview experience, which can provide valuable insights into how the interview process could be improved from the candidates' perspective. This two-way feedback ensures that both parties are engaged in a process of continuous improvement that enhances the overall quality and effectiveness of the interview stage.

Integrating Feedback Loops Across the Application Phases

Thanks to feedback loops in the active application phase, your company can collect further valuable data that will contribute to continuous improvements in the recruitment process. This will ensure that you not only react to, but also proactively address the needs and expectations of applicants.

Post-Application Phase: Optimizing Onboarding with Feedback Loops

Onboarding Phase: Streamlined Support and Integration

Effective onboarding is critical to ensuring that new employees are optimally integrated and can get off to a successful start. Feedback loops at this stage address initial concerns that could affect the satisfaction and performance of new employees.

First impressions: Right at the beginning of the onboarding process, you should gather feedback through short surveys or informal check-ins to capture new employees' first impressions and identify any immediate problems in their role or with the company environment.

Ongoing feedback sessions: Regular feedback sessions in the first few months help to monitor how new employees are adjusting and how satisfied they are with their roles. This ongoing dialogue enables you to make timely adjustments to their onboarding experience based on their needs and feedback.

Evaluating materials and training: Ask for feedback on the clarity and usefulness of onboarding materials and training programmes. New hire insights are valuable for improving these resources and better serving future hires.

Conclusion: The Power of Feedback

Every interaction candidates have can either enhance or detract from their overall experience. By strategically implementing feedback loops at every stage, companies can significantly improve how they attract, hire, and retain talent. This proactive approach also simultaneously fosters a culture of continuous improvement and strengthens the corporate culture. Ultimately, the strength of a company's recruitment strategy lies in its ability to understand and respond to feedback, whereby every point of contact with applicants helps to strengthen a robust and positive employer brand.

Get in touch